I really need to track down a bottle of Rain. I bought a huge (like 3oz!) bottle of his Grass scent on ebay that I like a lot.
I won't take it personally that you're ambivalent about Amber 
. I also don't love a powdery fragrance.
I love cucumber, but I was really torn between that and rain when I bought my cuke. I might have to check my neiman outlet to see what goodies they have.
How much is the Cucumber at the Neiman's Outlet?
I was at a store about to buy both perfume's but when I asked if it was tested on animals the girl working their told they did and I ended not buying them. Its really sad to hear because they did smell great.
