Yeah the guy is so arrogant that he went into the USC locker room and congratulated them after a real heartbreaker.


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120838/


Isn't the time before a game a pretty intense time of coordinating and thinking and directing and encouraging? I prefer a coach who doesn't spend that time screwing around with other coaches whether they're on his staff or the other team's. We should be grateful for this kind of rhetoric--smart money says it's already taped to each player's locker or on each piece of gear in the weight room--it stokes a fire in the guys that's already twice as hot as this time two years ago.


Football is not a nice game


Yep, ND wasn't anything special. That's why we pantsed Purdue on ESPN, Sweetheart. The images of Brock Spack still bring a smile to my face. Sure, that was all just a good QB--nothing to do with planning, scheming, or anything.

Brimley's pure genius.


Ugh. I still have terrible memories of watching the 1997 Purdue game (a 17-28 loss at Ross-Ade Stadium). A bunch of us were gathered in the dorm, watching the game. Bad enough to watch a bad loss, but it was even worse having to listen to the announcers call Joe Tiller "The Mastermind" approximately 8.7 million times over the course of the broadcast.


If you're asking stupid questions, is it really Charlie's fault that he chooses to ignore them?

I would say this was Willingham, or a member of his staff. But Ty was always happy with 6-5, and that contradicts the 8 wins statement.

I do give this guy a ton of credit for pointing out the contribution Mays made last year. Mays didn't get the credit he deserved for his performance in the second half of the season. But any credibility is quickly lost by his comment about "a different quarterback."


I can understand his frustration; he knows he's going to be Charlies bitch for the duration of both of their careers. Not exactly something to look forward to.


It has to be a Big N coach. No other coach outside of the Big N would mention Mike Hart.

Also, the extra heap of bitterness suggests a coach that was schooled by ND last year. So, yeah Tiller.


They say that being nice to your enemies is like putting a hot coal on their forehead. CW should compliment Purdue plenty and then pants them again.


I couldnt care less if Charlie ever talked to another coach before the game...his focus and attention to detail is amazing and a lot of that has to do with the hour leading up to game time...so it's fine by me if Mr. Quaker Oats gets ignored.


Check this link to see SI's 15 best college football plays of all time. The last play featured and ND's only mention: Leinert's last second ditch into the end zone. Ohh the pain, the pain...

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com.../ content.1.html


"Mastermind", eat more oatmeal, it'll help your mental acuity. Since it's in vogue, maybe you can sell your Alamo Bowl ring on Ebay.


My guess is Tiller too, and there's no small amount of Hector Projector the comments if they're his. Insert the name "Drew Brees" for Quinn and you've got Tiller's experience at Purdue in the last few years.

I'll add that Tiller seems really bitter that Purdue hasn't made the leap.

He often tries to say respectful things about ND, but they never seem heartfelt. His face looks pained when he says respectful things, as if he can't believe this job makes him eat shit like this.

This is all well and good with me, by the way. The Irish are not everyone's cup of tea, and had I not grown up with them, I could easily see myself hating them the way I hate the Yankees.

Well said about the SC game, Bill.


The consensus on Irish Illustrated, after one of the mods claimed that it was a coach who beat us, was John L. Smith. Considering how high Smith was on Brady Quinn, and considering the reference to Mike Hart, I can see it. Smith also strikes me as the kind of guy who would try to joke and jape with the opposing coach before a game, instead of doing any actual work.


Who cares who said it...there's going to be a lot more of it as we keep winning and embarrassing other teams. Let's enjoy everyone else's sour grapes moments as we keep on succeeding.


Ohio State fans scare me:

http://www.deadspin.com/sports/y...-day- 176349.php


That sounds like Tiller's plain-spokin' b.s.

I lost all respect for him when he threw his entire team under the bus in the media after their collapse last season--including assistant coaches.

Oh, and by the way, his house cleaning this year included purging guys that he recruited, but were "bad eggs" and then bringing in a half dozen jucos.

You want to know what kind of guy Tiller is? Watch how he perpetually jerks his QB's every year. Curtis Painter is the newest guy to be the "glory boy" who will sure to subsequently be ripped publicly after a bad game--and it will probably be against ND when a freshman 'backer gets two INT's.

Tiller is a miserable man, based on his press persona alone, and Purdue deserves their crappy 7-4 life and the Outback Bowl every year.

I was never happier last season than when we took them to the woodshed and I can't wait to do it again this year.
After that game the sideline reporter asked Charlie if he was pleased with the outcome and Charlie said, "You always have to be pleased when you hang half a hundred on a team."

Business is business. I don't give two rips if Charlie doesn't pat other coaches on the ass before a game.

Go Irish! Screw Purdue. Screw their ugly campus, their lame woman and their horrible coaches.


Hell yes Charlie's arrogant as hell. Winning four Super Bowls and taking a sixth round Big 10 QB and making him into a 2-time Super Bowl MVP will do that to a person.


Arrogance is acceptable if you can back it up. That absolutely had to be a Big 11 coach, and with the Hart reference, it could only be Tiller or Smith. My bet is on Tiller, as we know the man has no class. I wonder how painful it was for him last year, watching what was supposed to be an incredibly talented and extremely experienced defense just get thoroughly demolished by "just a good QB". I will give him credit for the Mays comment though. I'm going to have nightmares until I see how the new kids step in for him and Hoyte this season.


I still like "Yukon Cornelius" for Tiller, the bumbling old asshole.


You guys are so full of yourselves. You don't know for sure who it is and you start your same ol bull by jumping on a bandwagon and trashing a coach. Typical ND fans. Tiller hasn't ever beed disrespectfull to ND but you just assume it's him. My guess is that it was John L Smith. But then again you all can't stand anything that's said unless it's sucking up to a mediocre ND team. All the person did was state the truth.


My God, is there no end with you people?

For the last time: Fat Charlie Weis did not "make" Tom Brady.

Get. A. Clue.

I didn't write this, but maybe it'll help some of you hapless, deifying parrots understand.

http://iblogforcookies.com/iblog...0811/ index.html


Joe Tiller, thanks for stopping by. Joe Tiller, everybody!


I wouldn't be surprised if it was both Pops Fisher (Brimley's character in "The Natural") and Hannibal from "The A Team" running that garbage. Tiller fielded a bunch of Quitters last year and Smith benefitted from a rare CW mistake in overtime and he knows that a beat down of biblical proportions is on the way and will hasten that severance check from MSU. Players like Hart who miss 8 weeks with a hang nail but have "potential" make me laugh. I will take Walker's 25 carrys and 130 yds every time, especially inside the 10.


Ignoring the mike hart comment, any chance it was fulmer, he's the same guy who reported Alabama to the NCAA for violations?


For the last time: Fat Charlie Weis did not "make" Tom Brady.

Ben, why don't you try to convince Tom Brady that Charlie Weis did not "make" him? Brady seems to think he did.


Okay, let's pretend it was John L. Smith then. He's just as bad as Tiller with his band of 50 yard line flag planting yard ape/Juco transfers, as well.

The difference between Michigan State and Purdue is that you might hook-up with their woman, but you wouldn't hire a graduate to work for you. So, it's same bag of crap, different drawbacks.


Yeah, Weis didn't "make" Brady. And he didn't make Curtis Martin. And he didn't make. . . It's pure coincidence that when CW has been a position coach/coordinator that the players he had to help develop early in their careers turned into Pro Bowlers. It's pure coincidence that the Notre Dame offense improved by leaps and bounds with nearly the exact same personnel. How could we have been so fooled?!


DJ: Excellent come back.

I don't recall Tom Brady saying anything about Lloyd Carr when he was on 60 Minutes either. Hmm.

Belicheck and Weis also were the first to actually recognize that TB was good! Carr was too busy trying to keep Henson from playing baseball. How'd that work out again?


I believe your blog is way off course and as a result, so are these comments. Tiller has his opinions, but suffice to say he has rarely, if ever, been known to call out another head coach.

Talking, or trying to talk, to an opposing head coach before a game is very unlike him.


I believe your blog is way off course and as a result, so are these comments. Tiller has his opinions, but suffice to say he has rarely, if ever, been known to call out another head coach.

Talking, or trying to talk, to an opposing head coach before a game is very unlike him.


The quote was anonymous (it may even have been a composite). Assuming, arguendo it was Tiller making the comments, his reputation for not calling out other coaches would be intact.

The talking before the game that the unknown coach was referring to was the small talk/BSing that most coaches do before games. Weis does not. He spends the first part of the pre-game warmup watching the opposition. Really watching the opposition. Not to psyche them out, but to see if he can spot something.


I'd say Fulmer or Smith. Fulmer is like Carr: wins the games he shouldn't and loses the games that were "gimmes."

Tiller isn't the most tactful, but he rarely rips like that, if at all. It's been my experience that he's more congratulatory in nature than bristling.

As much as I bleed Black and Gold, I still find it pretty sad when barbs from both sides turn ugly. Yes, it's a rivalry and yes, there's bad blood, but the death of respect from both sides is pretty nasty.

This isn't a "Can't we all just get along" moment, but come on...let's stay classy, San Diego.

God bless,
JF


What I question is how some on this fine blog came to the conclusion that it must have been Tiller. What HAS HE DONE in the past that makes folks here think he said this?

Without a doubt, Tiller is opinionated and he'll let it be known at times. But since arriving at Purdue, he has yet to say anything close to this about a coach. He'll usually be candid about fans, or refs and once in a while his own players.


If limited to a choice between Tiller and Smith, I would choose Tiller. Smith, living and working in Michigan, would see, hear, and read about U-M on a regular basis, and would probably not have to resort to calling Mike Hart "the Michigan kid."

Who knows, and who really cares, who it was?


Exactly right DJ, who cares as long as Charlie is giving the old bastards a reason to be cranky.


Is there a link to that article?


People seem to have jumped to the conclusion that due to the reference to Hart (remember, in the direct quote he was called 'the Michigan kid') that therefore, it must've been a Big Ten coach.

Consider the possibility that it was a coach OUTSIDE the Big Ten who could not remember hart's name, since this coach doesn't face Mich. every year, and thus referred to the RB the way he did.


the key to this is
what coach thinks he could have beat ty and not CW,since he said ty would have won 8 games and not 9.(that sentence was enough to turn me red)

only matt leinart would say something this stupid in the heat of the moment.


For the visiting Purdue fans -

As we said in the bottom of the post, the consensus from those who alerted us to this quote was Tiller. That doesn't mean it wasn't Fulmer or Smith.

It does sound like a Big 10 coach with the Hart reference (unless Fulmer is just being sneaky) and while Smith beat Weis, Tiller suffered a pretty public home loss after routing ND the year before. Also, Tiller made some rather public comments about the Purdue team chemistry and how it was the fault of one player in particular.

We figured that if he had no qualms about calling that guy out (Pollard?) then he wouldn't hesistate to criticize Weis under the cover of anonymity.

Besides, the coach states that he wasn't sure if Weis put in new wrinkles each week. Seeing as how Fulmer played ND the week after Weis totally abandoned the run against BYU and spread out the offense only to then go heavy on the screen passes against the Vols, that would be an odd thing for Phil to say.


phat phil is sneaky,but those aren't his words.Bronco wouldn't say it either,nor would walt harris.I don't think paul johnson would say it.

now "that michigan kid" didn't even play purdue last year and stomped michigan state and even had a big run.

I wouldn't rule out tressel either.maybe a little too unclassy for him,but...


Maybe it's Willingham. He's the only coach that would refer to himself in the third person.


now "that michigan kid" didn't even play purdue last year and stomped michigan state and even had a big run.

Just because you don't play a conference opponent in a given season doesn't mean you completely forget about their big guns.


I was at a Brook Army Medical Center in San Antonio talking to a Colonel who is one of the cardiologists on staff. He happens to be a huge ND fan. We're talking ND football when a Lietenant walks in and he hears us discusing ND. He chimes in that he was a Purdue grad. The Colonel asks the young guy who invited him into the conversation, and to mind his own business. The Lieutenant walks out of the room with his head hanging low. I ask the Colonel if he was a bit too harsh on the young guy. He tells me the kid was lucky he didn't say he graduated from USC.


Although I don't think that Tiller has any love for ND (and vice versa), I kind of suspect it may have been Smith.

Judging by what I've seen from him--such as the 10 man on the field FG vs. OSU, followed by the "coaches are screwing it up" comment as he left the field--I get the impression that he doesn't really do any thinking beofre he opens his mouth. I can't remember the quote, but I seem to remember him having some flippant comments after the ND game last year, as well.


Willingham WOULD have tried to approach charlie weis before the game last year...but the language here doesn't fit his sparkle in his eye vague bullshit tone, anonymity or not. i agree-tiller.


People, people. Look outside the box. Tiller? Smith? That's too easy. An inside source (on the board at ND) says Weis said it about himself. It's the Art of War (which, incidentally, was Weis' favorite book growing up.) Cause paranoia amongst your enemies by plotting a conspiracy against yourself to detract your opponent's focus. It's also a hell of PR tactic. Pure Brilliance. Pure Charlie.


A mod on one of the ND boards said the quote came from a coach who beat ND last year. That means it couldn't be Tiller althoug it made sense to me too. That leaves us with John L. Smith, Poodle, and Tre$$el. I can't see Poodle because I think he knows Charlie is the real deal and wouldn't make a flippant remark about Brady and Willingham's coachin acumen. I'm thinking Smith, but wouldn't be surprised if it was tre$$el.


Sorry, who care who says this drivel? No one with integrety sends out comments like these anonymously. I'd be surprised if anyone ever said it.

Just my opinion for what it is worth.


Can't be Tiller -- he talks about guys returning on defense and being a year better....the exact opposite happened to him last year when he returned his entire starting defense and they proceeded to suck worse than any defense has sucked.

Tiller will never say experience is a good thing again. The tracks have fallen off that sorry program.


JF,


Please do not ever refer to the ND-PU game as a rivalry. ND only has one rival.


I'm a long time ND football fan and a big admirer of the program that Coach Weis is building. More than anything else, I've been impressed with the sense of professionalism that seems to characterize the team, as a single-minded focus on winning is a really great thing to see.

With all due respect, conversations like this one are somewhat silly, because it doesn't matter who was the author of the quote or how badly we beat his team last year. This is the kind of nonsense that ESPN makes into a 3-part mini-series. It has nothing to do with sport and everything to do with theatre.

Also, there's a really dangerous possible double standard being set when we laud Coach Weis for being pleased about "hanging half a hundred" on another team. I'd bet that if another coach had said something similar about doing that to Notre Dame,there'd be all sorts of talk about how classless it was.

I guess my point is just that, again, with all due respect, discussing things like this is really sort of pointless. That's why the 2006 season can't start soon enough...


All this talk of is-it-Tiller-or-isn't-it notwithstanding, I love the anonymous quotes in the Sporting News' preview. It's raare that the comments are snarky. More frequently, the coaches they quote give insight thaat you'll never hear from: (a) the journalism interns they use to gather data for the preview issues (b) on-the-record coaches.

The thing I remember most from last year was a prediction that Michigan was likely to have a poor season because it was stacked with talented but untough players.

The preview also said that Ohio St, would be killer.


Did I just read comments about Purdue women from ND fans? When it comes to quality of women, Purdue is Venezuala or Columbia when compared to ND. Have you seem some of the girls at ND who look like teenage boys? ND has the market cornerd on Ugly chicks; that is why St. Mary exists....to improve the ugly ratio.


12 Visitors Online

Name:

Email:

URL:

Comment:  ?

Commenting by HaloScan.com