niether
neither
Nell was the hottest sluttiest Carter ever! These two are the gayest and most boring.
Neither one of them - what's up w/ Aaron's Popeye size arms....dang!
You guys will have to help me on names, but the one on the left is hotter.
Neither. Both look like meth taking white trash.
Nick?! Yeah I think Nick is hotter LA> They are both fug though
Wow. doesn't nick look like he's in his late-thirties?
they both looks so greasy. yuck!
neither. and when did nick get so fucking greasy? he looks like someone just gave birth to him.
Which one of them is Jimmy Carter?
I think I just threw up a little in my mouth...
Hotter? More like sadder.
GG's Avatar! 
which one is higher is more like it.
In a few years they will make their own gay love movie:
Brokebrother Mountain
Neither.
Ewww
Neither. Even their sisters are fug.
Kiki Dundst... oh wait...
LOL lemure! So fuckin right!
Ugh, they are both so shady and unkempt-looking. did they graduate from Dirty Skeev Academy with KFed?
aaron looks like he has no teeth in that pic.
both of them when i cross my eyes
Neither. They look like the white fucking trash that they are.
Mad props to Nick for abusing Paris though. (j/k!!!!)
None of the above.
nick is much hotter. i miss him and paris together... well, sort of
I wouldnt mind resting the younger one's ankles on my shoulders for a few hours of Carter pounding. The older one could hold the crack pipe...
If we ever need proof that Hollywood chews you up and spits you out, here it is. I think Aaron's hand it he hottest thing about his picture. No wait is the streetlight, defintely the streetlight
WELL you failed to post Aaron's 18th birthday on 12/08!! So boo to you anyway.
The one who bottoms is sexier, which means both of them are.
They both are fug and what's up with their fug clothes!eww
eeeew!
uhm DEFINITELY neither.
Wow...SUCH a tough question!!! I can't POSSIBLE choose. There is no way to choose.
Jake - that was just so nasty...thanks for the visual too... 
)
I like Nick better, after all he used to slap Parasite, the other fug used to bang Hilary Duff right?
Nick doesn't seem as trashy as the other one. what's his name?
Ew I threw up my lunch in my mouth.
Who are these fugs?
GG's....
who the fuck??
tough choice MK... they are both skanks
neither, both of these guys look like shit.
Aaron! Hes a cutie
I am a crazy bitch who loves anal sex.
LMAO!! Fat Girl Jessica
Aaron got uglier. Nick, eh, I'd do him.
Christ neither.
Jessica! how the hell are ya?
Not and Notter (is that a word?) 
looks like perez just stole from you.
Gross
One's a pussy and one looks like he combed his hair with a pork chop - however shall I choose?
their ugly mugs are pissing me off every time I refresh! Dammit! Sorry, I'm hungover.
There is a guy, virtually out of the pic standing next to the guy on the right wearing a jacket just like the one the guy on the left is wearing. Question is, why? Don’t answer I don’t care!
And I get one is named Aaron and the other one’s Nick but which one is which…? Forget it, don’t give a flying fuck….
Who are they? What is their claim to fame? Don’t answer I really don’t want to know!
They are both fug!!!
Hey why is Perez H not giving credit. You had this posted here 1st. He post the same picture with caption sorta similiar to yours. What a JERK.
Ew gross...neither. They both look like poster boys for Proactive!
Yummie. A Carter sandwich. Hit them both!!!
Combed his hair with a porkchop - HA!!!
neither of them aged well.
Nick looks like he had his face smashed in with a frying pan. Plus the fact that he was Hilton's dildo.
Aaron at least got Hohan and Duff fighting over him.
I give the younger Skank Carter my vote.
boo
Perez Hilton totally stole this which one is cuter from you all! He is going DOWN big time, I am totally digging Dlisted and allthisnonsense and pinkisthenewblog a lot more than Perez Hilton. He is just ass kissing everyone and won't be saucy and he is self-promoting every 5 posts, which gets old. He said take it or leave it, and no people are leaving him. His 15 minutes are almost up.
they both make me feel icky.
Hrmmmm....the greasy one! No...the fat one!
Shit, I can't decide.
Gross.
Neither.
Pudgy, anemic-looking, greasy-ass, substandard singers of boy bands do NOTHING for me.
GD'm, they look seriously unappealing by the way they dress and how un-hygenic they both look. *ugh*
They need to lay off the Velveeta and Corn Dog snacks...F**king gross.
Nick is the lesser of the two evil's but neither is really good looking.
both are fugly
I don't get it...is this like, a trick question? Uhhhhhh.......
Jimmy
neither has ever been hot. Yuck.
Gen, I totally laugh at how you phrase things! Velveeta and Corn Dog Snacks
asking me to choose which brother is hotter is like asking whether i would rather start eating my hand or foot first. fucking gross.
Ick. Which is which?
Which one is hotter?
Come on, you CAN'T make me choose JUST ONE!!!
Thanks DSS! 
I LOVE Velveeta! It makes me cheesier than I already am! I agree about the trick question. There is no possible scientific answer to the question!
the greasy hair really does it for me
Ewww, anyways are there no good looking men for us to look at?
I am so sick of Brad, Toothy Tile, Tom CruiseDick Wad, give us some hot men MK,,please
neither.
Neither.
I think Aaron Carter and Kelly Osbourne have been sharing the same peroxide bottle! Is it red, is it blonde ... I can't decide.
I think this photo has been cut in half and put back together with the the Brothers Dim on opposite sides. That's not somebody else to Aaron's left wearing Nick's jacket. It's Nick. Look at the place where Nick's left arm and Aaron's right arm come together.
That's a bad pic of both of them.. Nick looks like he's lost some weight. Must've caught something from Paris...
Dark Sided Slut is right! After these 2 fugs, we need some Clive Owen!!!
i wouldnt mind doing then both at the same time
^Jan, I TOTALLY would slobber all over my monitor if Clive Owen's beautiful 'I want to f**k you' face was on it!
.....well, that is what he says to me in my fantasy involving him anyway!
*whew*.........
Both are crusty nasty!!
Is that a trick question?
neither totally hot.... but very fuckable!!!
their mom.
perez is a cock burglar. OMG, MK you're so hotter than him any day of the week! fuck him in his theiving ass!
Good catch, L. BOOGIE, I think you are exactly right.
Yuck!
Ugly mother-fuckers.
yuuuurk! What the hell happened to those boys?
Well, one's had his dick up in Paris Hilton and the other has had his meat inside Lindsay LoWlife (as well as Bruce Willis), so they both seem pretty tainted to me.
haha ya i use to think aaron but is neither a choice??
I thought Aaron was cute when he was dating Hilary Duff, but now he is so, so ugly. Thank god Hilary dump Aaron and now is dating Joel. I prefer seeing Hilary with Joel than Aaron.
don't you mean who is more fugly?
Geeesuhs! Faces of Meth!
Nick
Greasy stubble gets me hot!
nICK IS HOT!
WTF? Can you say Jethro and Goober? Ugly ass MF'rs!! Neither!!
Why the fuck does the guy on the right look just like the original blond haired guy from that old lame ass television show, 'The Dukes of Hazzard'? bleeeech!
NICK is SO sexy!! Sexiest man alive!!!!!!!!!
Since they're both not cute, I will pretend you're referring to temperature, in which case even tho Aaron is sporting the sweat-er, Nick looks sweat-y.
Wow when did Aaron Carter get so fat?
He used to be a skinny kid,right?
Must be all that bud he smokes.
Im gonna go with Jimmy - Jimmy Carter is cuter than these rats.
Neither. Well i'll go with anon 3.22 am.
Genevičve, I'd slobber too... I slobber on my monitor already cause I have a Naveen Andrews wallpaper. If Dlisted had some hot Clive Owen pictures, it would be perfection.
I saw Clive presenting an award at the Brit Awards just last week. I was in heaven, cause first Siouxsie presented an award to the Scissor Sisters, then Clive! I don't really remember who he gave the award too though, I wasn't paying attention to *that*.
They're both gross!
Aaron Carter!
If you like your man to have thin blonde hair, thin lips, or no talent --or, yikes, all three coveted attributes -- then they're equally hot. If you have more discerning tastes, the answer's Paris Hilton --who somehow manages to make those things work together nicely.
neither
ha ha
Well, I used to think Nick Carter was way hot.. in fact, when I was 11 or 12.. I thought I was going to marry him. That being said, he seems arrogant, stupid and anyone who puts their dick into Paris Hilton has AIDS. I am so sorry, but Nick, you will not be missed. As for Aaron, I'm pretty sure he was the first to bone Hil & Linds and turned them into whores. Good job, you fugly P.O.S.
They're both disgusting.
Normally, I would say Nick because he is sooo hot (at least he WAS). But these two are way foul-looking. And after dating that skanky, no-talent, leg-spreading Paris Hilton, I wouldn't touch him with someone ELSE'S 10-foot pole! Why is Aaron so fat, anyway? He must be smokin' a lot of the vile weed and visiting Taco Bell every five minutes. Either that or he caught something from Nick who caught it from the above-mentioned skank.
^OMG Jan, Shit, do you mean Siouxsie from 'Siouxsie and The Banshees'?....Oh Geezus, I totally love them, that girl is a f**king genius! She is a total goddess and I have been a huge fan for forever and a day! ('Cities in Dust' going through my mind as I type this, cool!)
Damn, Clive Owen and Siouxsie on the same show, that is HOT!
I totally did not see the Brit Awards, but I will have to see if they will rerun them on BBC America here in the states.
I'm kinda thinking Nick Carter is pretty hot right now. In the past I wouldn't have thought so. But he is. Damn.
It was great, first cause most of the nominees play decent music (no Mimi!). Second, yeah, THE Siouxsie, and Clive, in one place! Enough said... I'm gonna watch again when they rerun it tomorrow.
They played "Peek-a-boo" as intro music for her, hehehe.
Hey, Madrid - you been smokin' with Aaron? Cuz if you think Nick is hot in this picture, you must be fried!
Jesus H. None of the above. God, they both look like they've been hitting the white shit a little too hard again. SHOWER, dammit.
Neither is hot, but Nick is better looking...
I wish you a Merry Christmas
to ev'ry one on Dlisted
I wish you a Merry Christmas
and a Happy New Year.
Fun readings to you, and pics to laugh loud
I'm wishing a Merry Christmas
to the Dlisted crowd.
I hope you catch no syphlis
and no pains in your pissmas
and more fun than thiswas
to think up, and say.
I wish you all, a great time
and great sex that yule find
I wish you a Merry Christmas
and friends that are dear.
i tink dat there both hot but look erghhh!!! yukkkk!!! in dis pik wot eva happened to them there were soo nice b4 but now there just greasy i miss there good-lookin non greasy selfs lool
I don't know how you think these are fat guys, neither one is. But Nick is way hotter than Aaron. I want him.
are there more carter brothers to chose from cuz these two ain't happening.
Aaron's twin sister Angel! Oh shit...I can't believe I just admitted I knew he had a twin!
Neither.
Nick is cute.
Nick is really hot!
Ok...which is which...and is one of them Aaron? Good God! The one on the left looks greasy and the one on the right looks like Will Friedle after an 8-day benge on cream puffs and coke.
This is a crappy picture. They are both much better looking than that. Nick is a hottie for sure. Aaron's too young for my taste but he's cute, too.
I never thought I'd be an advocate for Mystic Tan.....
I read a blurb in some magazine a while back where Aaron said something about not wanting unattractive people around him so if you weren't good looking just stay away.
Dick.
Rosalynn
ewww is that really them? what the hell happened???
B, that is sad what Aaron said. I guess that means he can't be in his own company anymore because he isn't cute. I love it when people, who were cute and relied on their looks when they were younger, end up not so pretty. That's what happened to a lot of the cheerleaders and jocks in my high school. Hehehe.
neither their both ugly and im just trying to be nice now:D
Commenting by HaloScan
