I use Mac Technakohl (I think that is the name). It is thin enough that you can make it thin or thick. I usually make it very thin under my eye and never line further than my pupil. It doesn't smudge much either. But a little smudge after a long day is inevitable I think b/c of skin's oils.
I use CoverGirl perfect point plus in espresso. It smudges a little after the application on the lower lash line, but I just clean it up with a q-tip after I apply my mascara.
Bare Minerals by L'Oreal. It is like a powder and it comes with a brush. Tough to explain but it works WONDERS! I have the defyning onyx (I think) and I love it I will never go back to the pencil or anything like that again! Oh and you can get it at target
I use old motor oil. It's cheap (especially when you're doing an oil change), it doesn't go on too thick, and you don't have to press hard to get it to stick.
And if you hang around with chicks that dig the smell of old motor oil, then it doubles as a cologne.
You can thank me later. I know I'm a huge help.
I just bought a new one a few weeks ago that I love!
It was a Revlon Matte in black. Loving it. Sharpens easily to a point but can be smushed a little if you want as well. Also comes with the smudger on the opposite side. I always like the smudgers... 
I use a liquid liner. No ouchies and it's easily to control how thick you want it, just apply it in short straight lines rather than one long line. I use Almay liquid liner.
Thanks everyone! I've got my list. Now I just have to find time to go shopping! You all rock. 
Commenting by HaloScan
