GREAT piece... impeccable argument and logic.... Gilad is one of the most powerful living weapons against zionism alive today.
Good God Mr Atzmon, that is an amazing piece. Everyone who reads it will see themselves and point their fingers at someone else.
You will probably get a lot of flak for it, although it's the most reasonable argument imaginable. The concept of harm vs offence is really stimulating. It's going to give me a lot of food for thought and again I have to thank you for being so original and so timely with all of your insights. Really an outstanding piece this.
People don't like to be told that when they think they are being utterly GREAT to the minorities but are really just keeping the power balance satisfied.
Tx Jahman and Knuckles.... i was myself pretty shocked to find out how simple and banal Zio structuralism is
Can we not say plain and simple, Comparing Nazis and Israelis is wicked and unfair to the Nazis?
Thanks Gilad - a really timely and well written article 
"How is it that historical research that may lead to some different visions of past events that occurred six and a half decades ago offends those who live amongst us today? Clearly, it is not an easy task to suggest a rational answer to such a query."
Its actually quite easy. Rational historical inquiry offends no one, but the Holocaust denial industry is not about rational inquiry but rather trying to minimize the crimes of the Nazis by spreading anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. It's hate speech taking on scholarly airs, and nobody sees that better than historians. Anyone who isn't already an anti-Semite sees that quite clearly, which is why people like Irving and Zündel and Eisen have been rejected by essentially everyone but anti-Semitic extremists.
You have fallen in with a bad crowd, Gilad, and you're starting to cover for them when you say things like this. It's getting harder to believe you're doing it accidentally.
Well said, Gilad. You might be stating the obvious, but few will dare to speak it.
Thanks Mary
Ms. Rizzo, I apologize for writing an unpleasant content for you.
easy, Mr. Atzmon Mr. Eisen and Mr. Shamir are not Holocaust Revisionist.
easy, What kind of Jewish definition did Six Million use?
Zündel distributed "Did Six Million Really Die?".
Zündel tried to prove the correctness of "Did Six Million Really Die?" by the Toronto trial.
Mr. Atzmon distributed "The Holocaust Wars".
Mr. Atzmon, Why did you distribute "The Holocaust Wars"?
Mr. Atzmon, Did you distribute "The Holocaust Wars" by a pastime?
Mr. Atzmon is "3rd Category Jewish".
The concept is so simple: if the word holocaust brings Nazis to mind and an Israeli Deputy Defence Minister states that they (Zios) will bring a bigger holocaust upon Palestinians the circle is closed. Such a lapsus linguae tells more about the true nature of Zionism that a million claims for peace.
Gilad can of course clear up any controversy in a moment, by rejecting Holocaust revisionism as the playground of fascists -- as its history plainly shows. But doing so would take away one of the clubs he likes to use against the Jewish people, so instead he will simply talk circles wthin circles and wheels within wheels. Which wouldn't necessarily be a problem if he hadn't gone out of his way to link himself to the Holocaust denial movement by distributing Eisen.
A lot of people are waiting for the moment where Gilad finally condemns the Holocaust denial movement, but I don't think that day is coming.
I saw this is posted over at ziopedia as well. I wonder does Andrew pay Gilad royalties from his membership dues. Is Gilad part of anti-Semite trade is that how he subsidizes his mediocre musician’s income? If so it says a lot.
Easy jet, go back to your stalinist shtettle...
easy is Goodwin in one of his many pseudos. Some of his crap I don't put up, this one, I let go through because it shows his obesession with Eisen and his lack of interest in the atrocities going on in Gaza.
Human power, most of your post is stupid, but I know for sure that Andy does not give anyone any royalties for the reprinting of the material he puts up.
As a matter of fact, all of Gilad's material is first published in this blog, which is Gilad's home away from home, and from there it is freely disseminated to anyone who wants to reprint it. I used to want them to at least put a source link up, but now, I just don't bother, it gets in about 100 sites from here, so I am just happy it is out there and people read it.
Mr. Atzmon is "3rd Category Jewish".
Natural science | 03.08.08 - 6:08 am | #
--------------------------------------------------
------
Gilad, use self-reflection or rather self-intellectualization which is related to your mental state.
Muslims will finally kill you! Or maybe Israelis!?
________________________________________
Israelite, You should apologize to Ms. Rizzo for the spam transmission.
easy and Israelite, What kind of Jewish definition did Six Million use?
Mr. Atzmon, How could you intend to treat "The Final Solution to the Greenstein Question"?
Natural science,
Something is fucked up with your system. You should upgrade it, let's say to Vista.
What is funny about you Muslims is that when you murder, and you do it every day, you call it the global warming, but when others respond to your violence you call it genocide.
My post is a "spam transmission", whereas yours are the legtimate freedom of speech a Muslim earns due to his enlighenment and progress.
Do you understand what you're told?! What kind of creature are you. And worse. What kind of creatures visit this post that none have ever tried to understand if your a machine or human !
As for Mary, she is "3rd Category Jewish" as well.
________________________________________
"What kind of Jewish definition did Six Million use"
What a surprise from NS. Another expression of open anti-Semitism and Holocaust denial, how astonishing.
Condemn an anti-Semite for his anti-Semitism, and Mary will rage and hide your posts. But she never seems to manage to rage and hide the antisemitic ones does she. Far too busy presumably.
Poor old "easy" Goodwin, still hankering for a bit of attention from someone, anyone out there...
Hey easy, are you still weeping over your little fantasy that peacepalestine was deleted just to SPITE you, personally????
Oh, you had the PePas rolling in the aisles with that one.
But hey, a word of advice from a concerned citizen... next time you feel the paranoid urge to attribute personal meaning to random events which have nothing to do with your little existence, it's advisable not to shout about it too loudly, cost the men in white coats are going to get wind of it sooner than later.... and then, yes indeed, you're going to be escorted somewhere nice and peaceful.. with little birdies tweeting in the trees..... and not to SPITE you either, but for your own good
is it okay to call you "1st category asshole", Israelite, dear?
Ms. Rizzo, If Italy is truly reflecting on World War II, Venezia might have to be handed over to the Jewish.
If Germany is truly reflecting on World War II, Two States might have to be handed over to the Jewish.
Israelite, You should apologize to Ms. Rizzo for the spam transmission.
easy and Israelite, I was convinced that it was necessary to analyze you and to dissolve Israel as soon as possible.
easy and Israelite, Israel is never your mother countries.
easy and Israelite, We borrow here from Ms. Rizzo.
easy and Israelite, What kind of Jewish definition did Six Million use?
Commenting by HaloScan
