This is truly a brilliant and original piece... I don't know how Gilad manages to keep coming up with the best stuff..thanks Mary!
FYI, an interesting book review which analyzes the role of the willing dupes who refer to themselves as 'liberal internationalists'.
sigh. can't we just call a hudna between greenstein and gilad?
Will Greenstein get the Hamantash?
Greenstein should fast forever.
Greenstein withdrew accusation.
Greenstein must withdraw accusation.
Greenstein should attempt solving by a peaceful discussion.
Very erudite, very right, and very interesting about Lenin and the Bund.
Whatever reservations I have about PSC, they have done very well to not get distracted into hypotheticals like the 1 or 2 state arguments. They have alway stuck firmly to the position that "there already IS a road map - international law!" It's hard enough to get THAT message across to the wide public, without muddying the message with hypotheticals, not to mention insisting that potential Palestine supporters be interviewd by a panel of rabbis, to make sure they are pure of 'antisemitism'.
Talking about Hudna. It is more likely that we see first an Hudna between Hirsh and Greenstein.. Hirsh already offered his help the Green-eye man, then deleted the post cos Mossad told him he foolishly exposed Brighton Unemployed Sayan Centre.
Atzmon is OK with Greenstein, he loves him, he may even need him. Especially he likes him jumping around exposing what Talmud really means for secular Jew.
The Green man is the microcosmus of Zionism.
The righteous bank robber, the victim abuser, this is what Zionism is all about taking other people land and crying for hel, shooting and sobbing they call it.
Natural Science: "Greenstein should fast forever."
heh heh yes indeed. The austere life of an ascetic would do him good for a few years...meditating on the top of the mountain and all that. At the very least he may learn some manners and humility.
But while there are butcheries to be pilfered, chickens pieces to be lifted, old ladies to be mugged and other people's credit cards to foot the grocery bill, he's going to continue stuffing himself at the expense of the community.
Whenever I read about Holocaust, Jews and Palestinians, I can not help recalling the following joke:
Two gentleman are seating alone in a train compartment, when one of them, all of sudden, draws a gun and says to the other "Take it out and play with that!". The surprised cotraveller can not believe the request, but finally, after the gun repetition, does what he was requested. After some time, the first gentleman draws the gun again and demands the repetition of the operation. When the train stops and both gentlmen are going to get off, the second gentleman takes courage to ask the first one what happened to him.
"O, yes, nobody will rape me in a train any longer!"
Excuse me sir: you are not jewish, are you?
Very nice article...on a firts reading.
But after a quick inquiry on Wikipedia I found that, I quote,.."Gilad Atzmon (Hebrew: גלעד עצמון, born June 9, 1963) is a jazz musician, author and anti-Zionist activist, who has been accused of antisemitism, and who was born in Israel and currently (June 2005) lives in London.".."Atzmon has caused some controversy with his outspoken political statements. These are often criticised as anti-Semitic, or cited as evidence of Atzmon being a self-hating Jew. He frequently criticises the Israeli state, comparing it to Nazi Germany, and questions the political framing of the Nazi Holocaust.".."He has responded to accusations of antisemitism by questioning the existence of antisemitism itself; "Because Anti-Semite is an empty signifier, no one actually can be an Anti-Semite and this includes me of course. In short, you are either a racist which I am not or have an ideological disagreement with Zionism, which I have.".."He wrote, in an article entitled On Anti-Semitism: "[W]e must begin to take the accusation that the Jewish people are trying to control the world very seriously...American Jewry makes any debate on whether the 'Protocols of the elder [sic] of Zion' are an authentic document or rather a forgery irrelevant. American Jews (in fact Zionists) do control the world"...etc...etc.
So, how to understand your article on a second reading?
Commenting by HaloScan
