mentalblog.com comments:
don't you need to be retired for 5 years to be eligible?
And shouldn't there be a committee voting?
what's your vote?
P.S. The only commentator who might be retired is FOS.
Why do i get this when i click on the link?
Sorry, the page you requested was not found.
Please check the URL for proper spelling and capitalization. If you're having trouble locating a destination on Yahoo!, try visiting the Yahoo! home page or look through a list of Yahoo!'s online services. Also, you may find what you're looking for if you try searching below.
Let's see.
I'm new here, so for me it's between Tony's eloquence versus Schneur's sheer depth (oxymoron?) in knowledge of Chabad scandals & politics... I vote Schneur.
Tony 'barks up the wrong tree' on occasion.
Example: "The Rebbe's idea of Kiruv was fueled by Ahavas Yisroel... merely to make Judaism accessible to Jews. Not to turn them into Blackhatters."
What about Hafatzas HaMa'ayoneis? Curious...
Berl,Crown Heights gets my award for the most pompous and conceited poster, only his partisan views top his hubris
Hall of Fame, eh? Now my wife might finally show me some respect! I told her all those late hours in front of the computer weren't wasted. Ha!
Dispel gets my vote.
mvqm, what link are you clicking on? Anyone else sees the problem?
Berl and Shneur tie for my vote. Both are partisan and informative while neither is too partisan. I would love to be at a farbrengen with both of them present. Tony has much promise, but needs more time and experience and a little more eidelkeit. He can learn from my two selections.
Is this a blog requiem or just end of season MVP awards?
Anyhow, I vote for Gandalin, who is by far the most interesting (if infrequent) commenter.
Special awards:
Schneur & MIB – best archivists.
faruq – best conversation.
Dispel – most hartzig.
Tony & S.H. – best writing.
FOS – cutest.
P.S. Naturally I did not vote for myself only to demonstrate my humility (which, in turn, makes me an even greater Godol).
Berl is true to the style of his Excellency.
P.S. not the requiem.
wow berl, youre back!
tonys only been around since before pesach so we dont yet know that hes got staying power :)
so it boils down to berl and schneur.
at this point i think i'll have to flip a coin!
http://www.haloscan.com/comments...0319920/
#142669
this may have been the last of faruq?
this was not the last of him.
Hirshel Tzig seams like a nice fellow in person but he does his best to be a complete moron in his writings. For example the comment here. Who pulled his tongue to leve a not constructive negative jive. Not even true. And to boot he recommends a "committee" - an appalling, totalitarian vestige. What a Putz! What an idiot!
Schneur for sheer knowledge
for Berl האב איך נאך ניט די פאסיגע ווערטער, but I'll think of something soon iy"h
Berl,
Than you for your kind mention. Most of the things that Tzemach posts are either above my head or out of my experience, and being -literally- tabula rasa, I don;t have much to add about them. Occasionally, when I feel that a vort might not be unwelcome, I'll offer a thought.
I've always enjoyed the insights I've gained from the repartee between you and our host.
All the best,
Gandalin
berel, i'd like to see you start a blog.
DELETED one more negative jive
Edited By Siteowner
Commenting by HaloScan
