mentalblog.com comments:
Sounds a bit like another Chassidish cult we know and love...
you're an asshole
Breslovers should be marginalized in the religious world once again, as they were in the past.
yes right, let's break up jews into small little groups. Start with misnagdim...
Tine for you to stop posting again, if you're back in full rant mode.
Thank G-d, people know the score independently of you.
I am very superstitious , when I go to Israel I always visit Amuka and Meiron. I thought to go to Uman. For $1000+ I have a guarantee that he would grab me by my hair and take me out of hell. If I ever end up there.
There is nothing wrong with folk spirituality as long as the "folk" are decent to each other and to everyone who disagrees with them. Tzaddiks, saints, holy men, wise women,and angelic people who "might really be" angels bring distant heaven close to those of us who are only made of earth.
-going to uman ?
-land of the temeim ?
-if anything take the remains of reb nachman to israel.
-whatever happened to "hashem melo kol haaretz kevoydoy" ?
-uman? in a cesspool of unwashed chossidim for rosh hashone?
-reb nachman promised forgiveness? then died a meessas koress ?
(just like R' Y Lurie Ashkenazi?)
-is this jewish at all?
-you speak of not caring to be with sefardi talibans ?
-why, I find the most deranged and out of line tendencies in judaism today represented by oops ashkenazi card carrying "corrupt germanic" speaking (yiddish? they call it) both chossidish und litvish, true contemporary meenim.
-no wonder so many of you lose their bearings!
-yiiikes! why did I keep reading!
"-reb nachman promised forgiveness?
then died a meessas koress?
(just like R'Y Lurie Ashkenazi?)
-is this jewish at all?"
Not in the opinion of this former Catholic. I'm beginning to believe that the Baal Shem Tov must have been very influenced by the devotional practices of the Christian peasantry he must have lived near.
"rosh hashonah uman uman hey, "
let's all go there and enjoy a great rosh hashonah
yakhne,
if you are (married or not) of the female sex-as the name implies-, you can't go in Rosh Hashana, lest you be seen by boys and lest you be tempted to look at boys.
The boys leave their families -some even from Israel- to go to the land of the antisemites. Some mitzva! Besides, Rosh Hashana, is not meant to be great but is rather the first 2(of 10) Days of Awe.
Besides 2, I am told the hotels are not that great. but, who cares, just stay at home and pray to אלוקי ישראל, as מלוא כל הארץ כבודו
:)
firstly who said i am female i might be male that has a geshmack in the name oh yachne the great.
and 2 you don't need a great hotel to have a great time.
and 3 i would like to pray to e'lo'hay yisro'el as 'mloh kol ha'arez k'vodo in the holy city of uman.
a shiur by rabbi moshe tzuriel -in hebrew- indicating why it may be not such a good idea to go to uman.
in particular to those in israel.
it seems most of those in the diaspora, should be likewise discouraged. very interesting reading, i feel is very worthy to spread around.
what is this shiur you talk about? i do not see anything.
yachne the great
it was cutoff in transmission.
this blog apparently does not accept url's. go to a7.org stick to hebrew, go to yahadut,there is an article about uman. good luck
Malkizedeq, this blog accepts urls you, on the other hand, can't tipe and is a candidiate for a moron.
Malkizedeq,
........a moron.
????????????
whatever you say, this is your blog !
I am sorry.
Gut Shabbes to u TA.
all i have to say is one thing. we should all go to uman for rosh hashonah. i think we would all feel better if we do.
R' Yachne
I want to ask you humbly, why should we go to Uman?
Is there a tiqun that is achievable only by abandoning our families and fellow worshipers in the regular shuls we attend?
What with BT Berakhot praising that who prays @ the same place, and conversely, the shekhina misses him (kivyakhol) if he doesn't show up?
Do we have a "better shake"-so to speak- in the Ukraine?
Why? For me the Ukraine seems as alien as Mars, with the added disadvantage of anti semites outnumbering Jews.
Any special segulah there?
I will feel good as you say if I know that you and some other acquaintances on my case quite insistently, "would all feel better" there.
On my side, I rather be with my family and those who will share with us the Seder Rosh Hashana at home.
'I want to ask you humbly, why should we go to Uman?'
for the hell of it.
'Is there a tiqun that is achievable only by abandoning our families and fellow worshipers in the regular shuls we attend?'
no, but there are a lot of stuff that you do when you can achieve them many other ways.
'What with BT Berakhot praising that who prays @ the same place, and conversely, the shekhina misses him (kivyakhol) if he doesn't show up?'
i do understand what you are trying to ask here.
'Do we have a "better shake"-so to speak- in the Ukraine? '
that is a possibility.
'Why? For me the Ukraine seems as alien as Mars, with the added disadvantage of anti semites outnumbering Jews.'
i find that statement true of the u.s. of a.
'Any special segulah there?'
yes.
Commenting by HaloScan
