I hope he enjoys his stay of 12 months and 1 day in Gehinnom...
*spit*
I don't see why the article should talk about the neo-Nazis quoting Lilienthal's writings. What you're suggesting is a fallacy known as guilt by association.
Lilienthal's greatest phrase was:
It used to be that an antisemite was someone who hated the Jews. Now, unfortunately, (...) an antisemite is someone whom the Jews hate.
Of course, he was called an antisemite for it.
I don't see why the article should talk about the neo-Nazis quoting Lilienthal's writings.
Not quoting them, selling them. Neo-Nazis don't sell books which are merely critical of Israel. It isn't guilt by association if the point is that the writing appeals to a certain mindset.
Hmm... The Jew Lilienthal? Dead at 94. The jew Chomsky? Not quite dead yet (sadly!) - at 80.
I must wonder: is virulent anti-Zionism some sort of a lucky charm that brings its Jew advocates blessed longevity? Or is G-d cursing them with uncommonly long lives so that they can plotz while witnessing the State of Israel survive and prosper?
How interesting to come across these comments on Alfred Lilienthal. I just came home from attending the International Palestine Day of Solidarity at the U.N. A friend of mine who knew Alfred Lilienthal well and also happened to be there, asked me to try to find out for her if there was anything written concerning his death. She said she'd heard there was something in the Washington Post but was hard pressed to find anything on him. She considered him an extraordinary human being and was quite saddened at his passing.
"She considered him an extraordinary human being and was quite saddened at his passing.
Elissa | 11.24.08 - 11:00 pm | #"
Yes, so...so touching....
I hear that Hamas, Hezbollah, and other "fine, upstanding" Jew-killing organizations also miss him very much. So, do tell, Elissa, how was the hatefest you attended? Were there representatives from JewWatch.com or StormWatch there, as well? I hope you wore the appropriate Keffiyeh, too....[edited]
MTB, I'm not comfortable with the name calling at the end of your comment. This is supposed to be a frum blog, believe it or not. I have edited out the last four words.
May the great man rest in peace - he was indeed a tireless worker for Justice.
By the way the guilt by association claim remains entirely valid.
regards,
By the way the guilt by association claim remains entirely valid.
I answered the point. Got anything to contribute to the discussion?
That's really pathetic.
Commenting by HaloScan
